CALAVERAS COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS AGENDA SUBMITTAL
BOARD MEETING AGENDA
Receive draft Agriculture and Forestry
Element to the General Plan Update; Provide February 10, 2009
Agriculture and Forestry Element into the General
Dept: Environmental Management Supervisorial District Number
Contact: Agency All
Phone: Mary Mutz, Agricultural
Commissioner
754-6504 ext 3 .. ~..._--~--~_._--- ~,~ --~~--~----~-,--~-~-~ ._--------~--". '---'-'--~
Published Notice Required? Yes: No: X
Public Hearing Required? Yes: No: x
DEPARTMENTAL RECOMMENDATION:
Environmental Management Agency staff recommends the Board:
1) Receive the draft Agriculture and Forestry Element prepared by the Agricultural
Coalition,
2) Direct appropriate staff to work with the Agricultural Coalition and Mintier Harnish to
further refine and prepare the Agriculture and Forestry Element to be included into
the General Plan Update,
SUMMARY:
The Board recently directed its General Plan update contractor (Mintier Harnish) to continue
development of the County's General Plan Update, Since initiation of the update beginning in
2006, the Board has directed the incorporation of two "optional" elements to be separate
elements, These elements include the Water and Economic Development elements, The
Agricultural Coalition is also proposing that another optional element be added as a separate
element, namely the Agriculture and Forestry Element
The Agricultural Coalition consisting of representatives from the Calaveras County Cattlemen's
Association, Calaveras County Farm Bureau, Calaveras Grown, and the Calaveras Wine-grape
Alliance is a group of agriculturalists who advocate for agricultural interests in Calaveras
County, The Coalition believes the attached final draft of the Agriculture and Forestry Element
is ready to be provided to Mintier Harnish for review for edit and inclusion into the new General
Plan, The Department submits this draft at this time to avoid any delays of the General Plan
update due to inclusion of this Element
FINANCING:
To date, county funds have not been used in consulting services as part of the development of
this final draft Agriculture and Forestry Element However, staff have spent time working on the
final revisions of the document Any additional costs that may be incurred by Mintier Harnish
related to the inclusion of an Agriculture and Forestry Element are unknown at this time,
Board of Supervisors Agenda Submittal
Subject: Direction to staff regarding the inclusion of an Ag Element into the General Plan Update
Date: February 10, 2009 - Page 2
DISCUSSION:
On August 5, 2008, the Agricultural Coalition submitted to the Board, a draft version of an
Agriculture and Forestry Element to be included into the General Plan Update. On that date,
the Board directed staff to work with the Agricultural Coalition in reviewing and editing the
document so it reflects the format and direction of the new General Plan.
Per Board direction, staff has met with the Agricultural Coalition numerous times to update and
improve the content of the Agriculture and Forestry Element. The Agricultural Coalition recently
met with Robert Sellman, then Director of Planning, and John Taylor, Interim Director of the
Community Development Agency, to review and edit the content of the Agriculture and Forestry
Element. The Agricultural Coalition believes that inclusion of this Element into the new General
Plan will greatly help protect agricultural lands and sustain agricultural operations while
maintaining Calaveras County's rural character.
Members of the Agricultural Coalition will be addressing the Board on various aspects of the
draft Agriculture and Forestry Element and answering any questions the Board may have
concerning the document.
ALTERNATIVES:
1. Accept the draft Agriculture and Forestry Element from the Agricultural Coalition as
presented, and direct the preparation of a separate Agriculture and Forestry
Element. Staff is not recommending this alternative because the document should
be reviewed by Mintier Harnish for content and applicability and the Board will
ultimately need to determine as to whether to consider an additional separate
element.
2. Deny the recommendation of the Agricultural Coalition and direct staff to proceed
with the General Plan update without incorporating the contents of the draft
Agriculture and Forestry Element. This alternative is not recommended because the
elimination of agricultural land protection policies will lead to the removal of land for
food production, hasten development and destroy the County's rural character.
OTHER AGENCY INVOLVEMENT:
The University of California Cooperative Extension Director acted as the facilitator for the
document by coordinating meetings and editing the proposed Element.
The Community Development Agency reviewed the content of the draft Agriculture and Forestry
Element for formatting, redundancy and legal implications, without taking a position on whether
it should or should not be a separate element of the general plan.
County Counsel's office did a limited review for the purpose of identifying legal issues only and
does not make any recommendation.
Board of Supervisors Agenda Submittal
SUbject: Direction to staff regarding the inclusion of an Ag Element into the General Plan Update
Date: February 10, 2009 - Page 3